10 Dumb Reasons Teachers Got Fired

There’s something strangely unsettling about hearing that a teacher got fired for something completely ridiculous. As a student, you grow up thinking that teachers are protected by contracts, unions, and years of service. But the reality? Sometimes a teacher can lose their entire career over a single dumb mistake, or worse—something that shouldn’t even be a mistake at all.

Read our blog on reasons why teachers should be paid more

I’ve watched news stories, read firsthand accounts, and even seen it happen in my own school—teachers walking out, boxes in hand, fired not for being bad at their job, but for breaking unwritten rules or tripping over some silly technicality.

You’d think teachers, the very people we entrust with shaping minds, would be shown more understanding. But no. Some teachers get fired for things so absurd you almost have to laugh—until you realize they’re real.

So why talk about it? Because these stories say a lot about how twisted systems can be. They reveal just how vulnerable good educators are to bad decisions, snap judgments, and sometimes, just plain stupidity.

Below are 10 dumb reasons teachers got fired, shared in all their frustrating, head-shaking glory. Some of these still make me pause and wonder: How was this even allowed to happen?

10 Dumb Reasons Teachers Got Fired

• 1. Using the wrong red pen to grade papers

One teacher got fired because they marked a student’s test using a red pen instead of the district’s mandated green. That’s right. Not because of how they taught, but because of the color of the ink. Apparently, red was deemed “too aggressive.”

• 2. Posting a picture of themselves at the beach

Another teacher was let go after posting a picture of themselves in a bathing suit—on their personal Instagram—during summer vacation. The school board claimed it was “inappropriate.” But here’s the kicker: it was a one-piece. Fully covered. On a public beach. How is that even fireable?

• 3. Refusing to give students zeros

Yes, this happened. A high school teacher was fired for refusing to give students zeroes for incomplete assignments. Her reason? She believed in giving second chances and promoting effort. The school, however, insisted on a zero-tolerance policy… literally.

• 4. Accidentally farting during a presentation

A substitute teacher let one slip during a history lecture and tried to laugh it off with the students. Harmless, right? Nope. A parent complained that the teacher was “unprofessional and immature.” Terminated by the end of the week. Over a bodily function.

• 5. Showing a PG-13 movie with a signed permission slip

A science teacher showed October Sky to supplement a lesson on rockets. The movie was rated PG-13. She even had signed permission slips. But the principal claimed one scene was “too intense” and said she should’ve stuck with textbook material. Fired mid-semester.

• 6. Bringing in cupcakes with sprinkles shaped like skulls

On Halloween, a teacher brought cupcakes for her students—with cute little candy skulls on top. One parent freaked out, calling it “Satanic imagery.” The school didn’t even ask for the teacher’s side. Just escorted her out that afternoon.

• 7. Using sarcasm too often

This one hit close to home. A beloved English teacher was known for their dry, witty sarcasm. Most students loved it. But one parent thought it was “psychologically harmful.” After a formal complaint and zero investigation, she was gone.

• 8. Giving an “A” to a student who didn’t meet the grade criteria—on purpose

The teacher gave a struggling student an A to help them stay on the sports team, with full transparency and support from the student’s counselor. But administration decided the grade tampering was “inexcusable.” Fired for having compassion.

• 9. Quoting a rap lyric during a poetry unit

A teacher quoted a censored version of a Kendrick Lamar lyric during a lesson on modern poetry. A student recorded it, took it out of context, and it went viral. The result? Immediate dismissal. No explanation. No chance to explain.

• 10. Letting a student borrow deodorant

This one is almost unbelievable. A teacher kept a hygiene kit in her desk for students in need—deodorant, pads, travel soap. One day, a boy asked to borrow deodorant before PE. She gave it to him. Later, the school said it was “inappropriate touching” and terminated her contract.

My Thoughts

When I first started collecting stories like these, I honestly thought they were exaggerated. But the more I heard, the more I realized how easy it is for a teacher to get fired for reasons that have nothing to do with actual teaching.

It makes you wonder: Are we really protecting the educators who care? Or are we setting them up to fail over the smallest misstep? The truth is, some of the dumbest reasons teachers got fired had more to do with politics, image management, or one overly sensitive parent than anything that happened in the classroom.

Some might argue, “Rules are rules.” But when the rule is that you can’t wear open-toed shoes during summer school or that you’re not allowed to smile too much (yes, that’s been cited before), maybe the rules are the problem—not the teacher.

Teachers already face enough pressure. Standardized tests, low pay, crowded classrooms. The last thing they need is to be fired for being human.

So the next time you hear that a teacher lost their job, don’t assume it was their fault. Ask what really happened. Ask if it was one of those dumb reasons teachers got fired—because chances are, it was.